On Criminal Justice (Group 3 Facilitation)

My competitive nature comes out during trivia-like games, regardless of my ability to win. I was a little surprised at my lack of knowledge on the criminal justice system in the United States, especially when I had just been looking at stats from an assignment in another class. But I shouldn’t have been. There’s so much that I don’t know, and am curious how those things will grow in relevance to me. It’s humbling to hear Mr. Sanders’ story and of the terrible havoc incarceration wreaks on individuals and communities, especially communities of color. The lives of people in prisons matter, and we don’t get a Get-Out-of-Jail-Free card as a society for the consequences of this system we created.

Even though the clip from the documentary cut down on discussion time, I did appreciate the reminder of the documentary Thirteenth. I watched the documentary sometime ago with my fiancé, and I remember being greatly grieved. I hate the racial divisions in our nation, and I hate how people have been destroyed by hate and dehumanization. As I reflect on my desire to do something, I’m reminded of what I have to focus on even in just today, and am not surprised that I haven’t done more to act. Sometimes I need to stop thinking and just act, and have come to realize that that is a major growing area for me. One way that I would be interested in taking an action step is volunteering with local inmates. I have a couple of connections with people who work directly with the justice-involved who could help me take those next steps. Another step is to take time to read more about the prison industrial complex, who it impacts, and what are viable means to diminish the harm of the institution, if not totally abolish it. I have a long list of book recommendations from many people, including the book by Angela Davis that Lawrielle recommended.

One area that was also brought to the forefront of my attention was Restorative Practice. My field placement is working to incorporate Restorative Practice into its curriculum, and have applied some of its principles throughout the school year. It’s still in the early phases of implementation, and unfortunately circles have been regarded by some students as largely punitive in nature. However, I think that as circles become more embedded at the school, more students will catch the vision for them. I believe healing circles were particularly effective in one instance at the school. There have been a few thefts at the school, and it was understood among the staff that the incidents were largely occurring in one class. One theft was particularly damaging. A flash drive of one of the teachers was stolen that had many many years of hard work saved on it, and her backup file was corrupted. She thought that all of her work was lost. A healing circle was initiated, and it was recommended that the flash drive be returned in a jar near the office, no questions asked. Whether directly or indirectly related, the flash drive was returned, renewing the teacher’s faith in students at the school. Positive relationships between students and adults at the school are deeply valued, and to foster healing in the midst of wrongdoing, especially when someone or someones are causing harm, underscores the school’s commitment to be different from the traditional education system in the U.S.

In this conversation around the criminal justice system are ideas of belonging and safety. I would be interested to understand more of how incarceration originated, the thought process behind it, and how the system is utilized. I am hesitant to abolish incarceration completely as a means to de-incentivize violent crime and wrongdoing, but reducing the number of people of color behind bars would be a huge milestone in our nation.



3 thoughts on “On Criminal Justice (Group 3 Facilitation)

  1. OMG! I loved reading your story about the theft in your school and what they had done to resolve it. When it comes to lying and stealing, it is very very unlikely in any situation (small or large) that the person will come forward and admit their wrong. It is just one of those things that is shameful for a person to do even when caught. The only way to really deal with this is to allow the person to return the item without anyone knowing, and that really is the only way you can expect to resolve those types of situations. It is great the teacher was able to get her work and the flash drive back. Overall, your reflection on this topic was really thoughtful!


  2. Gabby,

    If it’s available over summer, you should look into the Mini-Course Diane Back and Beth Sherman teach on Restorative Practices. It was great and I left feeling like I could implement some new practices at my field placement! Also, you should look into the restorative programming at Skyline high school – “Skysquad.” The Skyquad is a group of high school students who host and facilitate restorative circles almost completely on their own. Some of the Skysquad students – and Amy McLoughlin, who heads the program – talked to our class. It was really awesome!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s